ABOUT MILL STONE LEGAL GROUP
At Mill Stone Legal Group, we believe no one should feel powerless after an accident. When someone is injured, life changes instantly — lost income, medical bills, transportation issues, and nonstop pressure from insurance companies.
Our attorneys are licensed in the states of Florida, New Jersey, and Pennsylvania, allowing us to bring broad experience and perspective to every case we handle.
25+ YEARS
YEARS OF EXPERIENCE
Today, Matthew represents injured Floridians across the state, people whose lives are disrupted by the negligence of others. He takes on the insurance companies, levels the playing field, and fights with purpose, precision, and unwavering commitment.
ABOUT US
A Practice Built on Relentless Advocacy and Personal Attention
Mill Stone Legal Group was founded by attorney Matthew R. McGuigan, a seasoned litigator whose career spans financial markets, major national law firms, and more than a decade of fighting for injured Floridians. Matthew is also a circuit court certified mediator and handles mediations for all types of cases.
Born in Boston and raised in Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, Matthew began his professional life as a licensed stockbroker in San Diego before entering the real estate and mortgage industry. In 2006, he returned to law school, earning High Honors at Rutgers School of Law — graduating in the top 10 percent of his class and making the Dean’s List every semester.
He went on to sharpen his trial and litigation skills at Blank Rome LLP, an international Am Law 100 firm, representing some of the largest financial institutions in the world. That experience showed him exactly how big, powerful entities operate — and how everyday people can get steamrolled without the right advocate by their side.
In 2012, he founded Mill Stone Legal Group with one mission: to fight aggressively for the injured and ensure every client receives the attention, access, and justice they deserve.
Big-Firm Results. Small-Firm Attention.
Our job is to move fast, protect your rights, and make sure you’re never pushed around by big, powerful insurance companies.
We combine the strength and results of a large firm with the personal attention of a dedicated local attorney. When you call, you reach your lawyer.
You get immediate action, clear guidance, and a relentless advocate fighting for every dollar you’re owed.
OUR PHILOSOPHY
We believe powerful advocacy can still be personal. We don’t chase volume or treat clients like case numbers. Your case gets the focus, time, and fight it deserves.
OUR PRINCIPLE
Our work is driven by a simple principle: You deserve a lawyer who knows your name, answers the phone, and fights relentlessly for what you deserve.
OUR COMMITTEMENT
We move fast, think ten steps ahead, and cut through confusion so clients always know where they stand and what comes next.
QUESTION ANSWER
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
Start treatment right away. In Florida, you must seek medical attention within 14 days to protect your PIP benefits. Don’t speak to the insurance company before you’re represented — call us first.
There are no upfront costs. You don’t pay unless we win. Our fee comes from the recovery, not from your pocket.
Yes. You will always speak directly with Matthew McGuigan — not a case manager, not a call center. That’s part of our small-firm attention and personal commitment.
We represent injured Floridians in:
- Car accidents
- Motorcycle accidents
- Commercial truck accidents
- Slip and fall injuries
- Nursing home abuse and neglect
- Wrongful death
These cases often involve medical bills, lost wages, long-term care needs, and pressure from insurance companies — and we fight aggressively to recover every dollar you’re owed.
Every case is different. Some resolve quickly; others require litigation. What doesn’t change is our pace. We move fast from day one to protect your rights and push your case forward.
No. Insurance companies are trained to minimize payouts. Tell them you have legal representation, then direct all communication to us. We protect your claim from the start.
Yes. We help clients find respected doctors who understand injury cases and document the treatment properly to support your claim.